5 Best Backup Heaters for Reliable Pool Warmth That Experts Recommend
Never be left with a cold pool again! Discover the top 5 backup heaters that provide reliable warmth, extend your swimming season, and protect your investment when your primary system fails.
When your primary pool heater fails, swimming season doesn’t have to end abruptly. Backup pool heaters provide essential redundancy to maintain comfortable water temperatures even when your main system experiences issues.
A reliable secondary heating solution can extend your swimming season, protect your investment, and ensure your family’s comfort without the frustration of cold water delays. The right backup heater balances efficiency, affordability, and ease of installation while complementing your existing setup.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!
Understanding the Need for Backup Pool Heaters
Why Your Pool Needs a Secondary Heating System
Your pool’s primary heater can unexpectedly fail at the worst possible time—like during a family gathering or cold spell. A backup heater ensures you’ll never face uncomfortable water temperatures or canceled swim plans. Adding redundancy protects your investment and extends your swimming season by providing immediate warmth when your main system falters. Plus, a secondary system can reduce strain on your primary heater, potentially extending its lifespan.
Common Primary Heater Failure Points
Pool heaters typically fail at three critical components: the heat exchanger (which often cracks after 7-10 years), the thermostat (causing temperature regulation issues), and the gas valve in gas heaters. Electrical connections frequently corrode in humid pool environments, while control boards can short out from moisture exposure. Pumps and filters that become clogged can cause heaters to shut down due to inadequate water flow protection mechanisms.
What to Look for in a Reliable Backup Pool Heater
When selecting a backup pool heater, you’ll need to consider several key factors to ensure you’re getting the right solution for your specific needs. From energy sources to installation requirements, here’s what matters most.
Energy Source
Gas heaters powered by natural gas or propane offer reliable and fast heating, making them ideal for larger pools or colder climates. The Raypak Digital Low NOx Gas Heater stands out for its powerful heating capabilities and quick temperature rise.
Electric heat pumps like the FibroPool FH255 provide an eco-friendly alternative that’s cost-effective for long-term use. These units work by transferring heat from the air into your pool water and perform exceptionally well in humid climates for pools up to 10,000 gallons.
Solar heating systems harness free energy from the sun, making them highly energy-efficient options. While dependent on sunlight availability, these systems can significantly reduce operating costs over time when conditions are favorable.
Energy Efficiency Considerations
Heat pumps typically offer superior efficiency in mild climates, using minimal electricity to transfer heat rather than generating it. Look for models with high COP (Coefficient of Performance) ratings and titanium heat exchangers for maximum efficiency.
Gas heaters provide rapid heating but consume more energy. Select units with low NOx emissions and high efficiency ratings to minimize environmental impact and operating costs while maintaining performance.
Solar systems cost almost nothing to operate but require sufficient sunny days to be effective. Their efficiency varies dramatically based on your location, available sunlight, and seasonal conditions.
Size and Compatibility Factors
Match your heater’s capacity to your pool’s volume—an undersized unit will struggle while an oversized one wastes energy. For example, the FibroPool FH255 works optimally with pools up to 10,000 gallons.
Consider your pool type carefully. Some heaters are designed specifically for in-ground pools, while others work better with above-ground installations. Check manufacturer specifications to ensure compatibility.
Don’t forget about climate adaptation—colder regions require more powerful heating solutions. A heater that performs well in Florida might be inadequate in Minnesota during early spring or late fall swimming seasons.
Installation Requirements
Evaluate the physical space needed for your backup heater. Heat pumps like the FibroPool FH255 offer slim profiles and versatile mounting options, making them suitable for limited spaces around your pool equipment area.
Check for included connections and fittings. Quality heaters typically come with standard 1½-inch compression fittings that simplify installation and integration with existing pool plumbing systems.
Consider professional installation, particularly for gas heaters which often require specialized knowledge of gas lines and venting. Proper installation ensures safety, optimal performance, and validity of manufacturer warranties.
Top 5 Backup Pool Heaters for Uninterrupted Swimming
Here are the top five backup pool heaters that will keep your swimming experience warm and comfortable even when your primary system fails.
Hayward H400FDN Universal H-Series Natural Gas Heater
The Hayward H400FDN delivers impressive 400,000 BTU output with 83-84% thermal efficiency. Its cupro-nickel heat exchanger ensures compatibility with most pools while meeting low NOx emission standards. The compact design (36.5″ × 29.5″ × 24″) features electronic ignition and accommodates both 2″ and 2-1/2″ plumbing connections, backed by a 3-year warranty.
Pentair MasterTemp High Performance Heater
Pentair’s MasterTemp offers versatile heating power ranging from 125,000 to 400,000 BTU to suit various pool sizes. The heater features a durable cupro-nickel or titanium heat exchanger and user-friendly digital controls. Compatible with both in-ground and above-ground pools, this low NOx model combines high efficiency with reliable electronic ignition for consistent performance.
Raypak 336,000 BTU Digital Electronic Ignition Heater
The Raypak 336,000 BTU heater provides robust heating capacity with its efficient cupro-nickel heat exchanger and digital electronic ignition system. Available in low NOx models to meet environmental regulations, this heater features an intuitive digital display for easy temperature monitoring. Its durable construction makes it ideal for residential pools requiring reliable backup heating power.
EcoSmart SMART POOL 27 Electric Pool Heater
The EcoSmart SMART POOL 27 delivers 27 kW (92,000 BTU) of power through an eco-friendly electric design. Its compact footprint houses corrosion-resistant titanium elements and a precise digital thermostat for temperature control. This electric alternative works excellently for smaller pools and spas, pairing perfectly with existing solar systems for an efficient backup heating solution.
Sta-Rite SR400NA Max-E-Therm Pool Heater
The Sta-Rite SR400NA Max-E-Therm generates 400,000 BTU with its Dura-Glas rust-resistant heat exchanger for extended durability. This versatile heater works with both in-ground and above-ground pools, featuring electronic ignition and an easy-to-read digital display. Its high-efficiency performance and multi-year warranty make it an excellent backup option for maintaining consistent water temperature.
Installation Tips for Backup Pool Heating Systems
Installing a backup pool heater requires careful planning to ensure optimal performance and safety. Here’s what you need to know about proper installation procedures and requirements.
Professional vs. DIY Installation
Professional installation is highly recommended for gas backup heaters due to complex safety requirements and local code compliance. Certified technicians ensure proper gas line connections, ventilation, and optimal system configuration. While some electric heat pumps might seem DIY-friendly, improper installation can void warranties and create safety hazards. The additional cost of professional installation typically pays off through better system efficiency, reduced risk of damage, and peace of mind.
Plumbing and Electrical Requirements
Gas heaters require dedicated gas lines with proper sizing, secure connections to your pool’s existing plumbing, and adequate ventilation systems to prevent carbon monoxide buildup. Electric heat pumps need dedicated 220V circuits with appropriate amperage ratings and weather-protected connections. Both systems require bypass valves for maintenance access and appropriate drainage solutions. Always confirm your existing infrastructure can support your new backup heater before purchase, as upgrades to electrical panels or gas line capacity might be necessary additional expenses.
Maintaining Your Backup Pool Heater for Longevity
Proper maintenance ensures your backup pool heater remains ready when you need it most. Regular care prevents unexpected failures and extends the lifespan of your investment.
Seasonal Maintenance Checklist
Pre-Season Check:
- Inspect for damage, corrosion, and worn parts
- Clean heat exchanger and components thoroughly
- Test all electrical connections and controls
During Operation:
- Keep air intakes and vents clear of debris
- Monitor performance and adjust settings as needed
- Maintain proper water flow and chemical balance
Post-Season:
- Drain and clean according to manufacturer’s guidelines
- Store in protected area to prevent weather damage
Troubleshooting Common Issues
Heat Pump Problems:
- Low performance issues often stem from clogged air vents or incorrect sizing
- Check thermostat settings and ensure proper air circulation
- Address leaks or corrosion immediately to prevent system failure
- Ignition problems typically relate to gas supply or dirty burner components
- Low flame issues require gas valve adjustments or vent system inspection
- Use a gas detector to identify leaks before they become dangerous
Conclusion: Ensuring Year-Round Pool Comfort
Investing in a backup pool heater is truly a smart decision for any pool owner. By choosing one of these five reliable options you’ll gain peace of mind knowing your swimming season won’t be cut short by unexpected heating failures.
Remember that proper installation and regular maintenance are just as important as selecting the right model. Whether you opt for the high-performance Hayward H400FDN the versatile Pentair MasterTemp or one of the other recommended systems your backup heater will protect your pool investment and keep the water inviting.
Don’t wait until your primary heater fails during a critical moment. Take action now to ensure your pool remains a comfortable retreat for you and your family regardless of what challenges arise with your main heating system.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do I need a backup pool heater?
A backup pool heater provides insurance against primary heater failures, which often occur at the worst times like during family gatherings or cold spells. It helps prolong your swimming season, maintains comfortable water temperatures, and reduces strain on your primary heating system, potentially extending its lifespan. Having a backup ensures you never have to cancel swim plans due to heating issues.
What are common failure points in primary pool heaters?
Primary pool heaters typically fail at the heat exchanger, thermostat, or gas valve. Electrical connections and control boards are also vulnerable due to moisture exposure. These components can deteriorate over time, especially with regular use and exposure to pool chemicals and weather conditions. Identifying these weak points helps in planning for an effective backup solution.
What types of backup pool heaters are available?
The main types include gas heaters (natural gas or propane), electric heat pumps, and solar heating systems. Gas heaters offer rapid heating but cost more to operate. Heat pumps are energy-efficient but work slower and less effectively in cold temperatures. Solar systems provide free energy but depend on weather conditions and sunlight availability.
How do I choose the right size backup heater?
Select a backup heater based on your pool’s volume, desired temperature rise, and climate conditions. Calculate the BTU requirements by considering the pool’s surface area and the typical temperature difference you need to overcome. Ensure the heater is compatible with your existing pool setup, including plumbing and electrical systems.
Can I install a backup pool heater myself?
While electric heat pumps might seem DIY-friendly, professional installation is strongly recommended, especially for gas heaters which have complex safety requirements and must comply with local codes. Improper installation can void warranties and create safety hazards. Always consult with a qualified pool professional for installation.
How much does a backup pool heater cost to operate?
Operating costs vary by type: gas heaters cost $200-$400 monthly, electric heat pumps run $50-$150 monthly, and solar systems have minimal ongoing costs after installation. Your local utility rates, pool size, desired temperature, and climate all affect operational expenses. Energy-efficient models may cost more upfront but save money long-term.
What maintenance does a backup pool heater require?
Regular maintenance includes pre-season inspections (checking connections, cleaning filters), operational monitoring (verifying proper heating performance), and post-season care (proper winterization). For gas heaters, inspect gas lines and ventilation. For heat pumps, keep coils clean and ensure good airflow. Most systems benefit from annual professional servicing.
How long do backup pool heaters typically last?
With proper maintenance, gas heaters typically last 5-10 years, electric heat pumps 10-15 years, and solar heating systems 15-20 years. Lifespan varies based on usage frequency, water chemistry, installation quality, and maintenance regularity. A backup heater generally lasts longer than primary heaters due to less frequent use.
